How do you answer the ACT question that asks whether the whole essay accomplished a stated goal, where the answer is a yes-or-no plus a matching reason?
The writer's goal questions on ACT English: judging whether an essay or paragraph accomplishes a goal stated in the question (for example, to summarize a process or argue a position), deciding yes or no by what the text actually does, and choosing the option whose yes/no answer and reason both match.
A focused answer to the writer's goal questions on ACT English: deciding whether an essay or paragraph accomplishes a stated goal by judging what the text actually does, then choosing the option whose yes-or-no answer and reason both match, with a routine for these whole-passage two-part questions.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this skill is asking
A distinctive ACT question, usually the last one for a passage, asks whether the whole essay (or a paragraph) accomplished a goal stated in the question, such as "to summarize a process" or "to argue a position". The answer is a yes or no plus a reason, and you decide by what the essay actually does, comparing the stated goal to the real content. The skill is judging the match between goal and content, then choosing the option whose yes/no and reason both fit.
Compare the stated goal to the actual content
The whole question is a match check between the goal and the essay.
So a well-written essay can fail a goal it does not pursue: an essay on cheese history does not accomplish the goal of describing how cheese is made, no matter how polished it is. Quality is not the question; match is.
The two-part answer
Like add-or-delete, these questions test both a decision and its justification.
The wrong reasons typically misstate the content ("because it never mentions the festival" when it clearly does) or cite something irrelevant ("because the essay is too short", "because festivals are fun"). The right reason names what the essay actually does relative to the goal.
Applying it to a goal question
Match goal to content, set the yes/no, then pick the accurate reason.
Why goal-versus-content matching is decisive
The writer's-goal question is the capstone of Production of Writing: it applies the relevance-and-purpose logic to the entire passage. The reliable method is to compare the stated goal with the actual content, decide yes or no, and then match the reason to what the essay does. The traps, a polished essay that pursued a different goal, or an option with the right verdict but a false reason, are defeated by this two-step check. It is the same discipline as topic development and add-or-delete, scaled up to the whole essay: the text's real content is the standard.
Try this
Q1. How do you decide whether an essay accomplishes the goal stated in a writer's-goal question, and what are the two parts of the answer? [Recall]
- Cue. Compare the stated goal to what the essay actually does: if the content does the thing the goal names, the answer is yes; if it does something else, no. The answer has two parts, the yes/no and a reason, and both must match, so a correct verdict with an inaccurate reason is still wrong.
Q2. A goal question asks whether an essay "persuades readers to vote", but the essay only neutrally explains how voting works. Is the goal met, and what is the reason? [Short explanation]
- Cue. No, the goal is not met. The goal was to persuade readers to vote, but the essay only explains the voting process without arguing a position or urging action. The matching reason names that mismatch: the essay informs about how voting works rather than persuading anyone to vote, so it does not accomplish the stated goal.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of ACT exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
ACT English (style)1 marksA question asks: 'Suppose the writer's goal was to describe the steps of making cheese. Does this essay accomplish that goal?' The essay describes only the history of cheese, not how it is made. (A) Yes, because it discusses cheese (B) Yes, because it is well organized (C) No, because it focuses on cheese's history rather than the steps of making it (D) No, because the essay is too shortShow worked answer →
The correct answer is (C). The goal was to describe the steps of making cheese, but the essay covers the history of cheese instead. So it does not accomplish the goal, and the matching reason is that it focuses on history rather than the process.
Why not the others: (A) discussing cheese is not the same as describing the steps; (B) good organization does not mean the goal was met; (D) length is not the issue. The yes/no (no) and the reason (it covers history, not the steps) must both match what the essay actually does.
ACT English (style)1 marksA question asks: 'Suppose the writer intended to argue that the festival benefits the town. Does the essay fulfill this intention?' The essay gives reasons and evidence that the festival boosts local business and tourism. (A) Yes, because it presents reasons and evidence that the festival benefits the town (B) Yes, because festivals are fun (C) No, because it never mentions the festival (D) No, because it includes a counterargumentShow worked answer →
The correct answer is (A). The intended goal was to argue that the festival benefits the town, and the essay does exactly that, giving reasons and evidence (boosts business and tourism). So it fulfills the intention, and the reason names that support.
Why not the others: (B) "festivals are fun" is not why the goal is met; (C) is factually wrong, the essay is about the festival; (D) including a counterargument does not by itself defeat an argument. The yes (it argues the benefit) and the reason (reasons and evidence) both match.
Related dot points
- Topic development and purpose on ACT English: judging whether a sentence, phrase, or detail supports the writer's stated purpose or the passage's main point, using the question stem to identify the goal, and choosing the option that accomplishes that goal rather than one that is merely true or interesting.
A focused answer to topic development on ACT English: judging whether a choice supports the writer's stated purpose or the passage's main point, using the question stem to identify the goal, and choosing the option that accomplishes that goal rather than one that is just true, with a routine for purpose questions.
- Adding or deleting information on ACT English: deciding by relevance to the paragraph's focus whether to keep or delete content, choosing the option whose action (add/keep or delete) and reason both match, and recognizing that off-topic information should be deleted even when it is true or interesting.
A focused answer to add-or-delete questions on ACT English: deciding by relevance to the paragraph's focus whether to keep or delete a sentence, choosing the option whose action and reason both match, and recognizing that true but off-topic content should be deleted, with a routine for these two-part questions.
- Introductions and conclusions on ACT English: choosing an opening sentence that previews the paragraph's or passage's actual content and a closing sentence that summarizes or completes it, matching the introduction or conclusion to what the text actually contains rather than to an unrelated idea.
A focused answer to introduction and conclusion questions on ACT English: choosing an opening that previews the paragraph's or passage's real content and a closing that summarizes or completes it, matching the sentence to what the text actually contains, with a routine for these framing questions.
- Organization and sentence order on ACT English: ordering sentences for logical flow and finding the best placement for a sentence by following the clues inside it (pronouns, transitions, and references that must point to something already introduced), and recognizing logical and chronological sequence.
A focused answer to organization questions on ACT English: ordering sentences for logical flow and placing a sentence by following its internal clues (pronouns, transitions, and references that must point back to something already introduced), and using chronological or logical sequence, with a routine for placement questions.
Sources & how we know this
- Description of the ACT English Test — ACT, Inc. (2025)
- Preparing for the ACT Test — ACT, Inc. (2025)