Why is the atomic mass on the periodic table rarely a whole number, and how do isotopes explain it?
Isotopes and average atomic mass: define isotopes, and calculate the weighted average atomic mass of an element from the masses and natural abundances of its isotopes.
A focused Regents Chemistry answer on isotopes and weighted average atomic mass: how isotopes differ in neutrons, why the periodic-table mass is a decimal, and the step-by-step weighted-average calculation the exam asks for in Part B-2 and Part C.
Reviewed by: AI editorial process; not yet individually human-reviewed
Have a quick question? Jump to the Q&A page
Jump to a section
What this topic is asking
The Core Curriculum requires you to explain that the elements occur as isotopes and to calculate an element's average atomic mass as a weighted average of its isotopes. This is one of the most reliable Part B-2 and Part C calculation questions on the Regents exam, and it explains why the atomic masses on the Periodic Table are decimals rather than whole numbers.
What isotopes are
For example, the three natural isotopes of hydrogen are protium (, one proton, no neutrons), deuterium (, one proton, one neutron) and tritium (, one proton, two neutrons). Because they have the same number of electrons and the same nuclear charge, isotopes of an element behave almost identically in chemical reactions; they differ measurably only in mass and, for unstable isotopes, in radioactivity. The Regents notation for an isotope is either the nuclide symbol or hyphen notation such as carbon-14.
Why the periodic-table mass is a decimal
This is why you never need to do isotope averaging just to find a molar mass for stoichiometry: the periodic-table value has already done the weighting for you. You only carry out the weighted-average calculation when a question gives you isotope masses and abundances directly.
The weighted-average calculation
The method is the same every time:
where each is an isotope mass and each is that isotope's abundance written as a decimal fraction (so becomes ). The fractions add up to . A plain average (just adding the masses and dividing) is wrong unless the isotopes happen to be equally abundant, which is a common trap.
Reading the question carefully
Regents questions phrase abundance as a percentage; convert it to a decimal before multiplying. Sometimes a question gives the number of atoms out of a sample (for example " atoms of mass and atom of mass "), in which case the fractions are and . Either way, the principle is mass times fractional abundance, summed.
Try this
Q1. An element has two isotopes: mass at and mass at . Show the setup for the average atomic mass. [1 point]
- Cue. .
Q2. Why is the atomic mass of most elements not a whole number? [1 point]
- Cue. It is a weighted average of isotopes of different mass numbers, so it falls between whole-number masses.
Exam-style practice questions
Practice questions written in the style of NYSED exam questions on this dot point, with worked answer explainers. The year tag is the paper they imitate, not the source.
Regents (Part C style)3 marksElement X has two naturally occurring isotopes. Isotope X-63 has an atomic mass of and an abundance of . Isotope X-65 has an atomic mass of and an abundance of . (a) Show a correct numerical setup for the atomic mass of element X. (b) Calculate the atomic mass. (c) Using the Periodic Table, identify element X.Show worked answer →
A 3-point Part C calculation that mirrors how the Regents tests weighted average.
(a) Setup (1 point): convert percentages to decimals and multiply each isotope mass by its abundance: .
(b) Calculation (1 point): , so the atomic mass is about .
(c) Identification (1 point): an atomic mass near matches copper (Cu) on the Periodic Table.
Markers reward a correct setup (mass times fractional abundance, summed), a correct arithmetic result, and naming the element from the periodic table. The answer must lie between the two isotope masses and closer to the more abundant one.
Regents (Part A style)1 marksAtoms of carbon-12 and carbon-14 differ in their number of (1) protons (2) electrons (3) neutrons (4) positronsShow worked answer →
A 1-point Part A item on the definition of isotopes. The answer is (3) neutrons.
Both are carbon, so both have protons (and electrons when neutral). They are isotopes, meaning they have the same atomic number but different mass numbers, so they must differ in neutrons: carbon-12 has neutrons and carbon-14 has neutrons.
The trap answers (protons, electrons) would change the element or the charge; isotopes differ only in neutrons.
Related dot points
- Atomic structure: describe the charge, relative mass and location of protons, neutrons and electrons, and use atomic number and mass number to count the particles in an atom.
A focused Regents Chemistry answer on the proton, neutron and electron: their charge, relative mass and location, how the atomic number and mass number count them, and how the wave-mechanical model superseded the Bohr and Rutherford pictures.
- Ions and nuclide notation: explain how positive and negative ions form by losing or gaining electrons, and interpret nuclide symbols to count protons, neutrons and electrons.
A focused Regents Chemistry answer on ion formation and nuclide notation: how losing or gaining electrons makes cations and anions, why protons and neutrons stay fixed, and how to read mass number, atomic number and charge from a nuclide symbol.
- Electron configuration and energy levels: write Regents electron configurations, distinguish ground state from excited state, and explain how electrons absorb and emit specific amounts of energy as photons.
A focused Regents Chemistry answer on electron configuration the New York way (shell notation such as 2-8-1), the ground state versus excited state distinction, valence electrons, and how absorbed and emitted energy produces bright-line spectra.
- The periodic table and its organization: explain periods, groups and the periodic law, and classify elements as metals, nonmetals or metalloids using position and physical properties.
A focused Regents Chemistry answer on how the periodic table is arranged: periods and groups, the periodic law, the families (alkali metals, alkaline earth metals, halogens, noble gases), and how to classify metals, nonmetals and metalloids from position and properties.
- The mole and molar mass: use the mole and gram-formula mass to convert between the mass of a substance, the number of moles, and the number of particles.
A focused Regents Chemistry answer on the mole and gram-formula mass: Avogadro's number, how to find the molar mass from the periodic table, and the mass-mole-particle conversions, using the mole formulas on Table T of the Reference Tables.
Sources & how we know this
- Physical Setting/Chemistry Core Curriculum — New York State Education Department (2002)
- Reference Tables for Physical Setting/Chemistry, 2011 Edition — New York State Education Department (2011)